Review 2025

Barriers to effective higher and degree-level apprenticeships: a systematic literature review and future research agenda

Higher Education, Skills and Work-based Learning
Journal · Vol. 15 · Issue 3 · pp. 595-611
Abstract

Purpose: The literature concerning higher- and degree-level apprenticeships (HDAs) in the post-levy era (2017–) is sparse and fragmented. Therefore, the purpose of this paper is to contribute to the international landscape of higher education work-based learning by identifying barriers to effective HDA programmes and outlining a future research agenda to address these. Design/methodology/approach: This study employs a systematic literature review methodology to explore barriers in HDAs. Adhering to PRISMA 2020 guidelines, the review follows a three-stage process to develop the sample. A meticulously designed search strategy uses targeted queries on the SCOPUS database, focusing on terms related to HDAs and their challenges. Inclusion criteria is set to papers from 2017 to 2024, covering book chapters and peer-reviewed journals in the English language. Articles were cross-checked with the Chartered Association of Business Schools (CABS) database, which refines the total to 68 papers. Data from these sources is then extracted and tabulated for qualitative content analysis. Findings: The systematic literature review of 68 manuscripts finds challenges are faced by apprentices, employers and training providers alike. This includes, but is not limited to, ethnically correlated performance, stigma, careers advice, job design, mentoring practices and the incorporation of technology. Two additional themes of pedagogy/andragogy and policy emerge. Originality/value: Based on the analysis, the paper suggests an extensive portfolio of future research focused on collaborative practices. If addressed, this yields the power to influence future legislation and subsequent implementation. © 2024, Emerald Publishing Limited.

Keywords

Author Keywords

Systematic literature review degree apprenticeship work-based learning work-integrated learning barriers Higher apprenticeship

Index Keywords

Author Affiliations
Innovation and Business, University of Staffordshire, Stoke-on-Trent, Staffordshire, United Kingdom
Funding & Acknowledgements
No funding information
References 10 References
1 Ahmad, Bilal, Teaching and learning ICPS: Lessons learned and best practices, Digitalization and Control of Industrial Cyber-Physical Systems: Concepts, Technologies and Applications, pp. 297-312, (2022)
2 Aït Razouk, Abdelwahab, Job quality: A challenge for the effectiveness of higher education apprenticeships, The Success of Apprenticeships: Views of Stakeholders on Training and Learning, 3, pp. 235-241, (2020)
3 Ansart, Sandrine, Reflexivity and management apprenticeships, The Success of Apprenticeships: Views of Stakeholders on Training and Learning, 3, pp. 59-65, (2020)
4 Baker, Denise, Post-levy apprenticeships in the NHS – early findings, Higher Education, Skills and Work-based Learning, 9, 2, pp. 189-199, (2019)
5 Beaudry, Jean Luc, Levelling up: towards decolonising apprenticeship learning, Journal of Vocational Education and Training, 75, 2, pp. 219-237, (2023)
6 Boehler, Doris, Supporting vulnerable youth – austria’s active policy of education and work integration with young people at risk, The Shifting Global World of Youth and Education, pp. 149-160, (2017)
7 Bravenboer, Darryll Willem, Can you credit it? Towards a process for ascribing credit to apprenticeships in England, Higher Education, Skills and Work-based Learning, 14, 6, pp. 1368-1385, (2024)
8 Bullough, Bonnie U., Barriers To The Nurse Practitioner Movement: Problems Of Women In A Woman’s Field, Organization of Health Workers and Labor Conflict, pp. 127-135, (2019)
9 Cárdenas-Robledo, Leonor Adriana, A holistic self-regulated learning model: A proposal and application in ubiquitous-learning, Expert Systems with Applications, 123, pp. 299-314, (2019)
10 Casey, Caroline, Player, Purist, Pragmatist: a comparison of employability strategies in access to the solicitors’ profession via alternative degree pathways, Studies in Higher Education, 49, 12, pp. 2625-2636, (2024)
Quick Actions
Full Text via DOI
Citation Metrics
1
Times Cited (Scopus)

References 10
Document Identifiers