Evaluation of an undergraduate nursing entrustable professional activities framework: An exploratory qualitative research

Abstract

Background: Entrustable professional activities (EPA) are mainly used in graduate medical education and professional development and have not been widely implemented in nursing undergraduate settings. Nursing EPAs were therefore developed by the Alice Lee Centre of Nursing to translate theoretical nursing competencies into clinical practice and as forms of standardized clinical assessment tools. Feedback from various stakeholders is required to further refine the framework. Objectives: To explore the perceptions and experiences of using the new EPA framework in nursing students and hospital and university clinical instructors. Design: An exploratory qualitative study using focus group interviews. Participants: Seven year-one nursing undergraduates, 12 year-two undergraduates, seven university clinical instructors, and 18 hospital clinical instructors participated in this study. Methods: The students formed five groups, while the clinical instructors formed seven groups, each consisting of three to four participants. Semi-structured interviews were conducted to explore stakeholders' experiences and perceptions of the EPA assessment framework. Thematic analysis was used to analyze the data. Results: Despite initial mixed reactions of confusion and relief, many students and clinical instructors commended the comprehensive and structured EPA framework and its emphasis on holistic patient-centered care. EPAs also allow flexible assessment methods, encourage critical thinking among students, and promote team-based care and peer teaching. However, the assessment using a two-dimensional matrix with multiple competencies for the EPAs, subjective assessment criteria, the lack of standardization using checklists, subjective assessment criteria, and the lack of, manpower, and time may potentially affect the accuracy of the clinical assessments. The effectiveness of the EPA framework was also dependent on the quality of feedback, students' intrinsic motivations, and learning environments. The refinement of EPAs and entrustment levels, a physical checklist, and an incorporation of EPAs into school curricula were recommended to improve practitioners' learning experiences. Conclusions: The use of EPAs in nursing education continues to be a novel and evolving process. There remains a need for a further refinement of the EPA framework to tailor to instructors' expectations and students' capabilities. © 2020 Elsevier Ltd

Keywords

Author Keywords

Competency-based education Nursing education clinical competence entrustable professional activities Holistic nursing

Index Keywords

adult clinical competence female human male medical education nursing student psychology Humans Students, Nursing Article interview learning environment Thematic analysis curriculum qualitative research motivation education Interviews as Topic physician nursing education middle aged patient care information processing Educational Measurement perception clinical article semi structured interview competency-based education workforce Education, Nursing, Baccalaureate Faculty, Nursing thinking Focus Groups Critical thinking checklist expectation clinical assessment standardization holistic nursing

Author Affiliations

Clinical Research Centre, NUS Yong Loo Lin School of Medicine, Singapore City, Singapore

Clinical Imaging Research Centre, National University of Singapore, Singapore City, Singapore

Funding & Acknowledgements

National University of Singapore, NUS

The authors would like to thank the National University of Singapore for funding this project with the Teaching Enhancement Grant. The authors would also extend their thanks to the National University Health System, Medical Publications Support Unit, for assistance in the language editing of this manuscript.

References 10 References

1 Angus, Steven V., Internal Medicine Residency Program Directors' Views of the Core Entrustable Professional Activities for Entering Residency: An Opportunity to Enhance Communication of Competency Along the Continuum, Academic Medicine, 92, 6, pp. 785-791, (2017)

2 Standard for Clinical Nursing Education, (2012)

3 Boud, David J., Peer learning in higher education: Learning from and with each other, Peer Learning in Higher Education: Learning from and with Each Other, pp. 1-184, (2014)

4 Braun, Virginia, Using thematic analysis in psychology, Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3, 2, pp. 77-101, (2006)

5 Choe, John H., Shortening the miles to the milestones: Connecting EPA-based evaluations to ACGME milestone reports for internal medicine residency programs, Academic Medicine, 91, 7, pp. 943-950, (2016)

6 Dewey, Charlene M., Entrustable professional activities (EPAs) for teachers in medical education: Has the time come?, Medical Teacher, 39, 8, pp. 894-896, (2017)

7 Pakistan Journal of Social Sciences, (2013)

8 Duijn, Chantal C.M.A., Am I ready for it? Students’ perceptions of meaningful feedback on entrustable professional activities, Perspectives on Medical Education, 6, 4, pp. 256-264, (2017)

9 Competency Based Education History Opportunities and Challenges, (2014)

10 Gardner, Aimee King, Entrustable Professional Activities (EPAs) for Simulation Leaders: The Time Has Come, Journal of Surgical Education, 75, 5, pp. 1137-1139, (2018)

Evaluation of an undergraduate nursing entrustable professional activities framework: An exploratory qualitative research

How to Cite