Article 2022

Comparison between Apprenticeship Learning and Traditional Learning in Students of Mechanical Engineering Vocational Education: A Case Study in Slovenia

International Journal of Engineering Education
Journal · Vol. 38 · Issue 3 · pp. 825-835
Abstract

The objective of the work is to present a longitudinal study that examines the impact of teaching approaches on occupational skills and competencies and the possibility of further education or employment. We compared two groups of students taught according to the same curriculum. The first group (N = 25) learned according to the apprenticeship learning style (apprentices), and the second group (N = 19) learned according to the school-based learning style (students). We found that apprenticeship students with better average results at the end of compulsory education enrolled in the apprenticeship style of education, but the differences were not statistically significant. Students had higher average grades in the first year than apprentices, but apprentices had higher average grades in the second and third year. In the third year, the differences were statistically significant. There was no statistically significant difference between the average grades of the final exam. This study concludes that different educational styles do not have a relevant impact on vocational skills and competencies when the curriculum is the same. This is the first comparative case study and the basis for other studies. Apprenticeship enables also equal opportunities for further education and a faster transition from school to work. It is indispensable for all those who are considering or have already begun to implement apprenticeship. © 2022 Tempus Publications. All rights reserved.

Keywords

Author Keywords

Apprenticeship work-based learning vocational education and training (VET) upper secondary education school-based learning

Index Keywords

Curricula Case-studies apprenticeship Apprentices Students Vocational education and training Work-Based Learning Learningstyles Apprenticeship learning Further education School-based learning Upper secondary education
Author Affiliations
🇸🇮 Osnovna sola Skofja Loka-Mesto, Skofja Loka, Slovenia, Faculty of Natural Sciences and Mathematics, Univerza v Mariboru, Maribor, Slovenia
Faculty of Natural Sciences and Mathematics, Univerza v Mariboru, Maribor, Slovenia
Funding & Acknowledgements
No funding information
References 10 References
1 Breen, Richard, Explaining cross-national variation in youth unemployment: Market and institutional factors, European Sociological Review, 21, 2, pp. 125-134, (2005)
2 Spotlight on Vet Anniversary Edition Vocation Education and Training System in Europe, (2015)
3 Developing Best Practice in Work Based Learning an Evaluation of the Career Traineeship Pilot, (2018)
4 Simulated Work Based Learning Instructional Approaches and Noteworthy Practices, (2017)
5 Work Based Learning as A Pathway to Competence Based Education, (2019)
6 Work Based Learning as A Pathway to Competence Based Education, (2019)
7 Does Work Based Learning Facilitate Transitions to Decent Work, (2018)
8 Work Based Education in Vet, (2020)
9 Learning in the Workplace Strategies for Effective Practice, (2001)
10 Skills in Business the Role of Business Strategy Sectoral Skills Development and Skills Policy, (2015)
Quick Actions
Citation Metrics
0
Times Cited (Scopus)

References 10
Document Identifiers
  • EID 2-s2.0-85174823241
  • Language English