Article 2023

“Pedagogical transformation” of apprenticeships through a competence-based approach in the Benin crafts sector

International Review of Education
Journal · Vol. 69 · Issue 3 · pp. 401-423
Abstract

This article examines the pedagogical transformation generated by dual apprenticeship training and its impact on the Benin crafts sector. Dual training combines vocational education at training centres with on-the-job training in workshops during the week. Graduates of this programme receive a certificate of professional qualification (Certificat de Qualification Professionnelle – CQP). For this qualitative research, the authors visited 7 training centres and 39 workshops to make direct observations. Using a life-history approach, they conducted formal and informal interviews with craftspeople and semi-structured interviews with CQP graduates, non-CQP graduates, professional association personnel, training centre staff and CQP trainers. This research was carried out in Parakou, the most important city in central and northern Benin. In total, 96 individuals were interviewed, using purposive selection to pick actors from professional associations, convenience sampling with non-CQP graduates and snowball sampling to reach other participants. The study is underpinned by social change theory, with an emphasis on the factors and agents of change. The research findings indicate that dual training has a favourable impact on skills development, competency transfer and job performance in the crafts sector. CQP graduates benefit from both theoretical knowledge and practical expertise gained during their training. Those who succeed in finding a job or even setting up their own workshop contribute to building a competence-based approach to apprenticeships and stand out in the competitive labour market. Craftspeople who are unable to stand out in the labour market face employment insecurity. The majority of the CQP graduates interviewed had developed high self-esteem and were proud of their valuable knowledge and their ability to deliver high-quality services to satisfied clients. This also affected their relationship with older generations of craftspeople in terms of contradictions in the execution of specific tasks in occupations. © 2023, UNESCO Institute for Lifelong Learning and Springer Nature B.V.

Keywords

Author Keywords

Apprenticeship dual training Competence-Based Approach Benin Labour market competition Pedagogical transformation

Index Keywords

training Vocational education competitiveness labor market certification craft production Benin [West Africa] Borgou Parakou
Author Affiliations
Faculty of Agronomy, Université de Parakou, Parakou, Borgou, Benin
Faculty of Agricultural Sciences, University of Abomey-Calavi, Cotonou, Littoral, Benin
Funding & Acknowledgements
World Bank Group, WBG
Funding text 1: A study conducted to assess the effects of this pilot experience found that skills learning improved (Walther ). As a result, the Benin government turned to donors for further technical and financial assistance. In 2002, Swisscontact, a foundation dedicated to the implementation of international development projects, was asked to provide its expertise to support the government in implementing its apprenticeship reform. Swisscontact launched dual apprenticeship training in 2003 with financial support from the Danish Development agency, the Swiss Development Cooperation, the World Bank, the French Development Agency and others (Davodoun ).; Funding text 2: Gauthier O. C. Atindehou () highlights the actors engaged in the delivery of this dual training in Benin, as well as the funding, which is mostly supported by foreign donors’ aid. Elsewhere, we have pointed out that the allocation of roles between the public and private sectors in the execution of this dual training is ineffective (Bankolé et al. ). According to the findings of this research, public institutions play a major role in the governance and management of this dual training. Also in an earlier article (Nouatin ), the author assessed the level of engagement of professional associations in the implementation of dual apprenticeship training in Benin. According to his conclusion, while the private sector is heavily involved in implementation and plays a moderate part in the curriculum design phase, it has little engagement in the programme during the evaluation phase (ibid.). Moïse Emmanuel David-Gnahoui and Madoué Florentine Akouété-Hounsinou () conducted an assessment study of this dual training in Benin. Their findings revealed inconsistencies in its execution, and the financial challenge. Edouard Yokossi () studied the development of skills learning using a competence-based approach in Benin. He demonstrates how vocational skills were created using the Developing a Curriculum (DACUM) method (ibid.). In a recent article (Bankolé and Nouatin ), the first two authors of the present article have outlined in broad terms the discrepancies between the concept of Benin’s dual apprenticeships as they were conceptualised, and how they are implemented in practice. Furthermore, they found that this dual system has boosted apprentices’ social cognitive capacities (ibid.).; Funding text 3: We thank the Swiss National Science Foundation (SNSF) and the Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation (SDC) for financing the LELAM TVET4INCOME project research under which this research was conducted. We are grateful for the input and logistical support of Dr Ursula Renold, Principal Investigator of the LELAM project. We thank the Benin team of the LELAM TVET4INCOME project, especially Dr Esaïe Gandonou for his contribution in improving the article, Dr Guy Sourou Nouatin for his contribution in preparing the manuscript, Dr Sylvain Kpenavoun and Ambroise Houedou for their verbal support. Finally, we thank staff of the head of Department of TVET (DETFP), the Fund for the Development of Continuing Vocational Education and Apprenticeship (FODEFCA), donors’ agencies, staff of professional associations, craftspeople and apprentices for their readiness to act as interview partners.
Direktion für Entwicklung und Zusammenarbeit, DEZA
Funding text 1: A study conducted to assess the effects of this pilot experience found that skills learning improved (Walther ). As a result, the Benin government turned to donors for further technical and financial assistance. In 2002, Swisscontact, a foundation dedicated to the implementation of international development projects, was asked to provide its expertise to support the government in implementing its apprenticeship reform. Swisscontact launched dual apprenticeship training in 2003 with financial support from the Danish Development agency, the Swiss Development Cooperation, the World Bank, the French Development Agency and others (Davodoun ).; Funding text 2: Gauthier O. C. Atindehou () highlights the actors engaged in the delivery of this dual training in Benin, as well as the funding, which is mostly supported by foreign donors’ aid. Elsewhere, we have pointed out that the allocation of roles between the public and private sectors in the execution of this dual training is ineffective (Bankolé et al. ). According to the findings of this research, public institutions play a major role in the governance and management of this dual training. Also in an earlier article (Nouatin ), the author assessed the level of engagement of professional associations in the implementation of dual apprenticeship training in Benin. According to his conclusion, while the private sector is heavily involved in implementation and plays a moderate part in the curriculum design phase, it has little engagement in the programme during the evaluation phase (ibid.). Moïse Emmanuel David-Gnahoui and Madoué Florentine Akouété-Hounsinou () conducted an assessment study of this dual training in Benin. Their findings revealed inconsistencies in its execution, and the financial challenge. Edouard Yokossi () studied the development of skills learning using a competence-based approach in Benin. He demonstrates how vocational skills were created using the Developing a Curriculum (DACUM) method (ibid.). In a recent article (Bankolé and Nouatin ), the first two authors of the present article have outlined in broad terms the discrepancies between the concept of Benin’s dual apprenticeships as they were conceptualised, and how they are implemented in practice. Furthermore, they found that this dual system has boosted apprentices’ social cognitive capacities (ibid.).; Funding text 3: We thank the Swiss National Science Foundation (SNSF) and the Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation (SDC) for financing the LELAM TVET4INCOME project research under which this research was conducted. We are grateful for the input and logistical support of Dr Ursula Renold, Principal Investigator of the LELAM project. We thank the Benin team of the LELAM TVET4INCOME project, especially Dr Esaïe Gandonou for his contribution in improving the article, Dr Guy Sourou Nouatin for his contribution in preparing the manuscript, Dr Sylvain Kpenavoun and Ambroise Houedou for their verbal support. Finally, we thank staff of the head of Department of TVET (DETFP), the Fund for the Development of Continuing Vocational Education and Apprenticeship (FODEFCA), donors’ agencies, staff of professional associations, craftspeople and apprentices for their readiness to act as interview partners.
Schweizerischer Nationalfonds zur Förderung der Wissenschaftlichen Forschung, SNF
Funding text 1: A study conducted to assess the effects of this pilot experience found that skills learning improved (Walther ). As a result, the Benin government turned to donors for further technical and financial assistance. In 2002, Swisscontact, a foundation dedicated to the implementation of international development projects, was asked to provide its expertise to support the government in implementing its apprenticeship reform. Swisscontact launched dual apprenticeship training in 2003 with financial support from the Danish Development agency, the Swiss Development Cooperation, the World Bank, the French Development Agency and others (Davodoun ).; Funding text 2: Gauthier O. C. Atindehou () highlights the actors engaged in the delivery of this dual training in Benin, as well as the funding, which is mostly supported by foreign donors’ aid. Elsewhere, we have pointed out that the allocation of roles between the public and private sectors in the execution of this dual training is ineffective (Bankolé et al. ). According to the findings of this research, public institutions play a major role in the governance and management of this dual training. Also in an earlier article (Nouatin ), the author assessed the level of engagement of professional associations in the implementation of dual apprenticeship training in Benin. According to his conclusion, while the private sector is heavily involved in implementation and plays a moderate part in the curriculum design phase, it has little engagement in the programme during the evaluation phase (ibid.). Moïse Emmanuel David-Gnahoui and Madoué Florentine Akouété-Hounsinou () conducted an assessment study of this dual training in Benin. Their findings revealed inconsistencies in its execution, and the financial challenge. Edouard Yokossi () studied the development of skills learning using a competence-based approach in Benin. He demonstrates how vocational skills were created using the Developing a Curriculum (DACUM) method (ibid.). In a recent article (Bankolé and Nouatin ), the first two authors of the present article have outlined in broad terms the discrepancies between the concept of Benin’s dual apprenticeships as they were conceptualised, and how they are implemented in practice. Furthermore, they found that this dual system has boosted apprentices’ social cognitive capacities (ibid.).; Funding text 3: We thank the Swiss National Science Foundation (SNSF) and the Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation (SDC) for financing the LELAM TVET4INCOME project research under which this research was conducted. We are grateful for the input and logistical support of Dr Ursula Renold, Principal Investigator of the LELAM project. We thank the Benin team of the LELAM TVET4INCOME project, especially Dr Esaïe Gandonou for his contribution in improving the article, Dr Guy Sourou Nouatin for his contribution in preparing the manuscript, Dr Sylvain Kpenavoun and Ambroise Houedou for their verbal support. Finally, we thank staff of the head of Department of TVET (DETFP), the Fund for the Development of Continuing Vocational Education and Apprenticeship (FODEFCA), donors’ agencies, staff of professional associations, craftspeople and apprentices for their readiness to act as interview partners.
Agence Française de Développement, AFD
Funding text 1: A study conducted to assess the effects of this pilot experience found that skills learning improved (Walther ). As a result, the Benin government turned to donors for further technical and financial assistance. In 2002, Swisscontact, a foundation dedicated to the implementation of international development projects, was asked to provide its expertise to support the government in implementing its apprenticeship reform. Swisscontact launched dual apprenticeship training in 2003 with financial support from the Danish Development agency, the Swiss Development Cooperation, the World Bank, the French Development Agency and others (Davodoun ).; Funding text 2: Gauthier O. C. Atindehou () highlights the actors engaged in the delivery of this dual training in Benin, as well as the funding, which is mostly supported by foreign donors’ aid. Elsewhere, we have pointed out that the allocation of roles between the public and private sectors in the execution of this dual training is ineffective (Bankolé et al. ). According to the findings of this research, public institutions play a major role in the governance and management of this dual training. Also in an earlier article (Nouatin ), the author assessed the level of engagement of professional associations in the implementation of dual apprenticeship training in Benin. According to his conclusion, while the private sector is heavily involved in implementation and plays a moderate part in the curriculum design phase, it has little engagement in the programme during the evaluation phase (ibid.). Moïse Emmanuel David-Gnahoui and Madoué Florentine Akouété-Hounsinou () conducted an assessment study of this dual training in Benin. Their findings revealed inconsistencies in its execution, and the financial challenge. Edouard Yokossi () studied the development of skills learning using a competence-based approach in Benin. He demonstrates how vocational skills were created using the Developing a Curriculum (DACUM) method (ibid.). In a recent article (Bankolé and Nouatin ), the first two authors of the present article have outlined in broad terms the discrepancies between the concept of Benin’s dual apprenticeships as they were conceptualised, and how they are implemented in practice. Furthermore, they found that this dual system has boosted apprentices’ social cognitive capacities (ibid.).; Funding text 3: We thank the Swiss National Science Foundation (SNSF) and the Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation (SDC) for financing the LELAM TVET4INCOME project research under which this research was conducted. We are grateful for the input and logistical support of Dr Ursula Renold, Principal Investigator of the LELAM project. We thank the Benin team of the LELAM TVET4INCOME project, especially Dr Esaïe Gandonou for his contribution in improving the article, Dr Guy Sourou Nouatin for his contribution in preparing the manuscript, Dr Sylvain Kpenavoun and Ambroise Houedou for their verbal support. Finally, we thank staff of the head of Department of TVET (DETFP), the Fund for the Development of Continuing Vocational Education and Apprenticeship (FODEFCA), donors’ agencies, staff of professional associations, craftspeople and apprentices for their readiness to act as interview partners.
References 10 References
1 Education Au Benin Etat Des Lieux Et Roles Des Parlementaires Et De Letat Beninois Education in Benin Current Situation and Roles of Beninese Parlamentarians and Government Rapport Detude Study Report Porto Novo Assemblee Nationale Du Benin, (2019)
2 Informal Competition and Productivity in Sub Saharan Africa, (2016)
3 La Formation Professionnelle Par Apprentissage De Type Dual Au Benin Le Dispositif Les Acteurs Et Le Financement Quel Bilan Vocational Training by Dual Apprenticeship in Benin the System Players and Funding What is the Balance Memoire De Formation Training Dissertation Centre Africain Detudes Superieures En Gestion Cesag Dakar, (2013)
4 Baba-Moussa, Abdel Rahamane, La prise en compte de la relation entre formation et emploi dans la réforme de l'éducation au Bénin : contribution à l'élaboration d'un nouveau modèle éducatif, International Review of Education, 63, 5, pp. 631-656, (2017)
5 Afr Educ Res J, (2020)
6 Dual Apprenticeship in Benin Strategic Actors and Roles, (2019)
7 Informal Sector in Francophone Africa Firm Size Productivity and Institutions, (2012)
8 Les Cahiers Centre Beninois De La Recherche Scientifique Et Technique Cbrst, (2015)
9 Lapprentissage Traditionnel Dans Lartisanat Au Benin Traditional Apprenticeships in the Craft Industry in Benin, (2011)
10 Lapprentissage De Type Dual Dans Lartisanat Au Benin Dual Apprenticeship in the Craft Sector in Benin, (2011)
Quick Actions
Full Text via DOI
Citation Metrics
1
Times Cited (Scopus)

References 10
Document Identifiers