Article 2007

Undergraduate requirements in restorative dentistry in the UK and Ireland

British Dental Journal
Journal · Vol. 203 · Issue SUPPL.5 · pp. 9-14
Abstract

Objectives To ascertain the requirements in restorative dentistry that undergraduate dental students have to fulfil in order to sit the finals examinations in dental schools in the UK and Ireland and to compare those requirements with the competencies stipulated by the GDC in The first five years.Methods Fifteen anonymised questionnaires, of open and closed question design, were sent by post to academics in the university departments of restorative dentistry in each of the undergraduate dental schools in the UK and Ireland. The first section concerned numerical information regarding total numbers of procedures that were required to be completed in undergraduate restorative dentistry. The second section was designed to ascertain information as to how decisions are made with respect to an undergraduate's readiness to sit the finals examination in restorative dentistry (such as continual assessment and/or competency assessments).Results A total of 15 replies were received for analysis, a 100% response rate. Several institutions emphasised that they do not have 'requirements', but provide guidelines as to what should be achieved. Six institutions did not have set numerical requirements for direct placement restorations or bridges. The number of direct placement restorations required at the other nine institutions ranged from 50 to 160. Five institutions did not have numerical requirements for dentures; four institutions did not set numerical targets for crowns, veneers, inlays/onlays or endodontics. In institutions where numerical requirements were not used, forms of competency assessments were completed. The requirements across all institutions for periodontology, integrated treatment planning and completed cases were ill-defined.Conclusions This study shows that there is a wide disparity amongst institutions in the UK and Ireland with regards to finals requirements in restorative dentistry. Ideally, such requirements should be similar between institutions and should be closely mapped to the GDC's required learning outcomes (The first five years) for the UK institutions. © 2007 Nature Publishing Group.

Keywords

Author Keywords

Not provided

Index Keywords

human Humans Article curriculum education United Kingdom Educational Measurement competency-based education standard Ireland dental education Education, Dental health care organization Dentistry, Operative Great Britain dental surgery Societies, Dental
Author Affiliations
School of Dental Sciences, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, Merseyside, United Kingdom
Division of Dentistry, School of Dental Sciences, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, Merseyside, United Kingdom
Funding & Acknowledgements
No funding information
References 10 References
1 Cabot, Lyndon Bruce, Are graduates as good as they used to be?, British Dental Journal, 186, 7, pp. 318-319, (1999)
2 Patel, J., Undergraduate training as preparation for vocational training in England: A survey of vocational dental practitioners’ and their trainers’ views, British Dental Journal, 201, s5, pp. 9-15, (2006)
3 First Five Years, (2002)
4 undefined, (2007)
5 Damien Walmsley, Anthony, GDC visitations--on their way out?, British dental journal., Suppl, (2006)
6 Evans, Anne W., Assessing competence in surgical dentistry, British Dental Journal, 190, 7, pp. 343-346, (2001)
7 Developing Student Autonomy in Learning, (1988)
8 Dodge, William W., A preliminary study of the effect of eliminating requirements on clinical performance., Journal of dental education, 57, 9, pp. 667-672, (1993)
9 Stacey, M. A., The effect of clinical targets on productivity and perceptions of clinical competency., Journal of dental education, 62, 6, pp. 409-414, (1998)
10 Holmes, David C., Student productivity in a comprehensive care program without numeric requirements., Journal of dental education, 64, 11, pp. 745-754, (2000)
Quick Actions
Full Text via DOI
Citation Metrics
21
Times Cited (Scopus)

References 10
Document Identifiers